Many people know about Kristallnacht and the tragedies that took place during those two horrible days in Germany but few know about the Vélodrome d’hiver round-up that took place in France.
I just recently finished reading Sarah's Key. It takes place in France during the Vel d'Hiv and in the present. It follows the story of a fictional character named Sarah that lived during the Holocaust and was taken during the round up. The other half of the book is about a journalist that has to write an article on the Vel d'Hiv and winds up getting caught up in the story and learning some horrible dark secrets about the apartment she is moving into and about her in-laws. Throughout the story the journalist's story becomes intertwined with Sarah's story.
The book is terribly sad, but very good. I had never thought much about what happened in France during Holocaust, but after reading this book I decided to do some research.
The Vel 'd Hiv was the biggest roundup of Jews in France. It took place on July 16th and 17, 1942. The round up was carried out by the French police, and not the Nazis. Over 13,000 Parisian Jews were dragged from their homes and placed in the Vel d'Hiv to wait. The Vel 'd Hiv was an old stadium building for motorcycle races. It has recently been torn down.
For two days all the Jews that were in the Vel d'Hiv waiting to know what would happen to them next. Finally they were taken from the building and put on trains. They were taken to a concentration camp called Drancy. While there the women and children were separated from the men. For several weeks they lived in horrible conditions in the camp. Finally the women were sent "ahead" of the children to Auschwitz. They were promised that their children would meet up with them a little later. Finally the children were sent as well.
None of them that made it to Auschwitz lived.



Holly cow! that image was enough to make us get on our knees and thank God we are Americans.
ReplyDeleteThis is a story worth reminding us of. I heard France is having lots of problems, the muslems are targeting the Jews now. Next, we will get another attack, I guess they don't know who to hate next. On that*** Happy Thanksgiving.
yvonne
Happy Thanksgiving.
I just wanted to read this again.
ReplyDeleteGod only knows we have a lot to be thankful for.
Hope you had a nice Thanksgiving,
yvonne
stop over to my post you will love it,, hope all is well.
ReplyDeleteyvonne
I am reading Sarah's Key now - which prompted me to do a search of Vel' d'Hiv.
ReplyDeleteI am reading Sarah's Key now and I just looked it up because I never heard about it, I think I am going to do my research paper on it.
ReplyDeleteJust finished Sarah's Key ~ I had not heard of the round up at Vel d'Hiv. Staggering and ever so sad to see what man will do to his fellow man and/or child
ReplyDeleteI just started Sarah's key and its really sad and terrible.. searching for some other informations.
ReplyDeleteI like many who posted above am reading Sarah's Key right now and decided I had to find out more. It's just unbelievable that they really did this awfull stuff. Makes me realise how blessed I am ! I knew about what happened basically and the concentration camps but until you read it and see pictures....I can't quit thinking about those poor people.
ReplyDeleteAs a child of a survivor of the camps of Poland, I was astounded to find out about what happened at the Vel d'hiv. I never knew this before. It amazes me that the police of France so willingly escorted and imprisoned toddlers and children, even going so far as ripping the terrified tots out of their mothers arms. It's especially shocking because these monsters had children of their own. How could anyone who professes to love a baby do this to another baby. The only thing standing between these men and their family's safty was the fact that they were born to christian parents, but at a flip of a coin they could have been born Jewish and then it would be their little ones terrified faces and grief stricken screams coming from the Vel d'Hiv. I wonder if they ever thought of it that way.
ReplyDeleteSarah's Key made me cry! Even though we have read stories about these things before we need to be reminded over,and over,and yet history keeps repeating itself. Why? Why do countries love war, killing, and hate? As a Christian I could never condone what was done to the Jews or to any other people! We have to be very careful not to instill hate of any kind in our children.
ReplyDeleteA mother of two son's
i also have just finished Sarah's key and looked up on the internet to find out more.An untold story which should be brought to light and told to everyone.With so many children sent to their deaths the truth never got out
ReplyDeleteSarah's Key is worth its weight in gold.
ReplyDeleteI was extremely moved by "Sarah's Key". Very disturbing and thought-provoking; it kept me up at night reading and reflecting. All along I thought of France as a victim in the atrocities of the Nazi Regime. I had no idea of the role that the government played in the thoughtless execution of these poor families. My heart aches.
ReplyDeleteI too have just read Sarahs key and wanted to learn more about what happened in france on July 16,17 1942. What I found amazing is when I talked to an older French woman about the book she imediatley said that she had heard about it but didn't want to talk about it. She was there during the war but had no idea about what had happened to the Jews.
ReplyDeleteThat made me sad to think that even after all these years people don't want to talk about it. We need to talk about it in memory of all those children who suffered and died a horrible lonley death.
I just finished reading the book today. Everything that happened at Vel d'hiv that summer in 42 really touched me. I'm aware that everything that is mentioned in the book and Sara's story isn't true, but I bet that there is someone out there that maybe has a similar story, not every detail, but something like it. I think that it's amazing how some people risked their lived to protect and take care of jews.
ReplyDeleteBut I think its horrible how the frenchmen were able to kill their own people just because they had a different background. It hurts me to hear about it. I was not aware that there was anything like it before i read the book. This story should be known to more people than it already is.
Touching
I just started Sarah's Key, given to me by a Jewish friend. I had never heard of the Velodrome d'hiver before or anything about France's involvement in the holocaust. I was immediately drawn to do research about this place. Why isn't it taught in history classes in school? No mention of it at all.
ReplyDeleteI actually don't know why it isn't mentioned in history books. I wonder that myself. Where I go to school people are constantly telling me that the holocaust didn't happen, though. It's really ridiculous. I just went to a conference about supporting Israel and speakers were talking about how people will do anything to call Jews liars and fakers and how they are completely guilty people and not innocent so they will do anything to deny the horrible things that happened to them during World War II. I think that is really and truly awful. There are so many witnesses and survivors and so much evidence to prove that it happened.
ReplyDeleteI find comfort in the fact that so many of you are feeling exactly how I am right now....just this morning I finished reading "Sarah's Key" and was so moved by it. I only wish that there was more I could do now for those innocent people. I guess the best thing we can do is to remember always the victims of all the camps. My heart aches for them and the survivors.....if there are any survivors reading this, please know that this young mother will never forget. God bless...
ReplyDeleteI just finished Sarah's Key, which prompted me to do more research on Vel d'Hiv.
ReplyDeleteThis summer I have read several books on children during the War, If you were moved by Sarah's Key you may like Children and fire by Ursula Hegi and A pinch of time by Claude Tatilon.
im reading a book called 'Sarah's Key' by Tatiana De Rosnay. its about the vel' d'hiv round up. its very deep and understanding it'll make you cry, we will never forget the children who were rounded up as the french did
ReplyDeleteI am just starting Sarah's key and was curious about this, so like all before me I have looked it up. What a terrible situation, and time!
ReplyDeleteI am a social studies teacher, took many history classes in college, and knew nothing about this. I knew the Germans took over Paris, but had no idea of the roundup of Jews. I finished the book, based on a suggestion from my mom who was reading it. I will add this book to my classroom library for my students to know and remember what happened there. And I will also make sure to add the roundup to my lessons on WWII and the Holocaust!
ReplyDeleteI have just finished reading "Sarah's Key" in two days. I could not put it down. I also knew nothing about the horrific happenings and what transpired ,in Paris,France 1942. The roundup of innocent Jewish citizens, including children at Vel'd'hiv was something that none of us should ever forget. Unfortunately many of us do not know about this occurrence. We should all look out for our fellow man and stop walking around with our eyes closed.
ReplyDeleteI began reading Sarah's Key this morning and am almost through with it. Through the years I have read and taken courses about the atrocities committed during WWII but have never read what took place in Paris in 1942. This book will lead me to search for more information concerning the occupation of France.
ReplyDeleteAm in the midst of "Sarah's Key," and yes, it is heart-wrenching. What I take from many stories, both fiction and non-fiction, about this time is a very sobering awareness that any one of us, I even, could stand by without helping, without trying to stop this kind of atrocity. People were taught to believe over a period of time that a particular group, Jews, were somehow the cause of people's troubles. Scapegoated, marked, hated. This could happen so easily again. Anti semitism has not gone away. Nor have other types of hatred and prejudice. We need to be careful with our judgments and actions.
ReplyDeleteAnti-semitism is very strongly there. Look at president day Israel! Palestine wants them destroyed, and not because they want Israel's land, but because they simply hate Jews. Same with Iran. Something we should fight against, if we can.
ReplyDeleteMy book club has chosen Sarah's Key to read this month. I never heard of the round up in France. Jesus wants us to love one another, he was a Jew by the way. Christians need to stand up for their fellow man. They didn't do it during the war and we are not doing it now. Don't be the silent majority again! People will be targeted because of race, religion,etc., because satan is alive and well on this planet. If you don't believe he is behind hate, then you are playing into his evil hands. If you don't believe it then you won't stop it.
ReplyDeleteI am French and I knew about the Vel d'Hiv. I don't remember where I learned about it, but it was not made quite clear to me at the time that the French police took it upon themselves to do more than the Germans had asked. They were asked to round up men. The Germans did not want nor need the women and children.
ReplyDeleteI could not put the book down and finished it at 2 am last night. So many children...
But before you blame all the French for not reacting... remember how many Germans went on to acclaim Hitler when he spoke!! and they claimed for years that "they did not know!!" I also believe that when your country is occupied by the enemy, you don't want to find out certain things. You'd rather play "ostrich" and bury your head in the sand. It still happens nowadays!
I also wanted to say that when growing up in France, my parents took my brother and I to visit one of the "transit" camps like Drancy. This one was the Struthof, in Alsace. We visited in late December and it was cold and the snow was very wet. I never forgot what I saw there: crematorium, piles and piles of shoes, piles and piles of hair!! It was "just a transit camp". The only bodies cremated there were of the sick who died there. It had a profound effect on me. I was maybe 13!
ReplyDeleteI am grateful my parents and grandparents never hesitated to talk about that period to us, the younger generation.
Hello, thanking you for commenting on this post. I'm sorry if in my post I made it seem that I blamed all the French for what happened during the Holocaust in France. I was just trying to state that the French took over for the Germans in rounding people up.
ReplyDeleteYour comment on the cremation piles and shoes gave me chills! If you don't mind my asking, what year was this? I have to say I'm glad that not all of France is in the dark about what happened. When I was in Europe we toured concentration camps in Germany but I had no idea about anything in France until one of my history professors, (someone who's era is the holocaust) told me about it and suggested Sarah's Key to me.
Thank you again for all the comments!
I am in the middle of reading Sarah's Key and decided to do some research on Vel' d'Hiv'. I am horrified. I am a teacher of 11-12 year olds. In our class library we have many books on the Holocaust of which none mention Vel' d'Hiv." My students will be learning about about what took place in France in the summer of '42.
ReplyDeleteToday I finished Sarah's Key. Words cannot describe the hollow feeling it has left inside me. The disbelief. I can't even begin to imagine the horror and torment those people went through. And as for the French government and police involved.... it just leaves me speechless. I will NEVER forget.
ReplyDeleteSarah's Key is a must read. It will help us remember the past to help make the future better.
ReplyDeleteI live in France, but also speak english. I just started reading Sarah's key and had never heard a thing about 'Vel d'hiv'! I learnt how shamfull and horrible this all was and can't beleive I had never heard of it! To anyone who hasn't read it, I strongly recomend it!
ReplyDelete(I just wrote a comment but I am not sure if it went through so I am re - submitting it. Sorry if this is a repeat.) I sobbed when I closed the book at the end. the hardest part is knowing the event was true even though the book was fiction. When they described how the children were "torn" from their mother's arms, I couldn't help but think about today's issue of abortion. Those women would have done anything to save their babies. Today women willingly have babies "torn" from their womb. It makes me wonder how we can easily diminish the value of life in our society and at the same time be horrified about what the Nazis did?
ReplyDeleteThe book was amazing,the ructions that went on there were terrible. I am saddened also that most of our generation and the now future generation will have to fall upon this tragic incident by mere chance, this should be in the books
ReplyDeleteI am reading Sarah's Key now and had to look to see if these events really did happen. I am amazed to find they did. How could I have never heard of this before. Yes the atrocities in Poland and Germany but did not know how the French Government also tortured and arrested and killed their own people. It is such a sad story but I think it should definitely be told.
ReplyDeleteI've read Sarah's Key several times and can't get over the horror of it all. My daughter's family just got home from a week in Paris today and along with Euro Disney, the Eiffel Tower and The Louvre, I wish my grandchildren would also have learned about the Vel'd'hiv. I will be sure to tell them. What a great tragedy.
ReplyDeleteYes, Sarah's Key is an astonishing book, most successfully blending historic fact with enthralling fiction. Many have said their schooling (American & French) didn't explain this event. One college student says her school / classmates are actively advocating that the Holocaust did not happen. I sincerely hope he/she is making sure to clarify that it DID. Regarding the "blind eye" of the French to the roundup . . . be careful, Americans, to be too quick to scorn. We also "rounded up" innocent Japanese Americans and relegated them to years of life in Interment Camps. Definitely NOT on the scale or horrific murders of the Holocaust - but we are not innocent. Let us all read & learn. Let us all remember. Let us all speak up when hatred and prejudice rears its ugly head - so that it will not happen again. Zakhor. Al Tichkah.
ReplyDeleteI just stumbled onto Sarah's Key while browsing at Barnes & Noble. I finished it within 2 days. I am shocked and saddened at what happened back in 1942 in the middle of July. My heart aches for those families ripped apart, especially the children. My mother was 3 years old at the time, but luckily born in the heart of America. I shudder to think at how one's fate can be determined so callously. Mahatma Ghandi said An eye for an eye will make us all blind. I will not forget what happened at Vel'd'hiv and make sure my children learn about it as well when they are old enough to understand. It takes all of us to stand up and speak against all evil, including abortion, the greatest moral evil of all time.
ReplyDeleteI've just finished watching the film Sarah's Key after following a link from The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas.
ReplyDeleteI was moved by this story, even if fictitious, the events happened and if I had not seen this film I too, like many have written before me would not have known what happened in Paris in July 42.
I am the mother of a Muslim, and I truly believe that faith is personal and that others should not be forced to feel the same way. If this was done then we would never have any issues with religion...maybe.
Oh the benefit of hindsight, it's a shame we don't learn from it (i'll leave you to interpret what that means).
I just watched the film Sarah´s Key, how come I never did know about this..!!! We were never taught or told about it... It´s really a shame, sad, really there are no words. Sometimes you really don´t understand what´s on others people minds... they are just crazy, don´t know that word but it´s definitely awful...
ReplyDelete1/7/2012, 4:00am, I am a 64 year old gentleman living in Western Massachusetts. The book was given to me by my sister several weeks ago. Initially the book remained untouched on the nightstand in my bedroom where most of my reading takes place. The night that I reached for the book and began reading I was tired from the day's events, however, managed to get through the first twenty or thirty pages. It awakend long forgotten memories. The second time I picked it up it was several weeks later and could not put the book to rest. For the next six hours tears rolled down my face, I was reminded of stories told to me as a young boy by the noted Dermatologist, Dr. Alfred W. Hollander. His stories of escape from Nazi Germany, only to be matched by his wife Trude, who told of her own ordeals of escape. Their close encounters always etched forever in my memory. Fifty years later I still ask "Why", will we ever understand the inhumanity of man?
ReplyDeleteTo those who are glad to be Americans: The Drancy camp looks an awful lot like the FEMA camps that have been erected in the U.S. These FEMA camps will hold over 1 million people, those suspected of being threats to our national security.
ReplyDeleteThe courage of Tatiana de Rosnay, in writing "Sarah's Key", hopefully will inspire others to unearth such events. How many other atrocities have been, are now, or will in the future remain hidden from our awareness ?
ReplyDeleteI visited Dachau last year. I came away with the message that WE MUST NEVER ALLOW THIS TO HAPPEN AGAIN.
What can we, as individuals, do ? We must question our leaders and demand answers. We must demand transparency. We must live our own lives with compassion and love.
We must never succumb to hatred and scorn of any human being, until we know their reality?
I can't get enough of the research on the Vel D' Hiv, especially after reading/watching Sarah's Key. Amazing!!! I had no idea that so many precious lives stolen in such a hanus way! I thank God for freedom!
ReplyDeleteMay the fallen never be forgotten and may they rest, finally IN PEACE!
I just this moment finished Sarah's Key -- I could not put the book down and read every moment I could catch - even reading until 3 am! I also never knew about this incident and shocked by the French -- but then not so much...Being Catholic and having many Jewish friends, I could never forget these horrible events. Unfortunately many of these types of things happen today -- Africa - Middle East .. where hatred and intolerance continue ... How I wish we could learn from our past and live in peace. But evil lurks everywhere and it is up to use to be on guard and make sure that this NEVER EVER HAPPENS AGAIN in our life times.
ReplyDelete